JWT and Vodafone Egypt are facing a huge backlash in Egypt after a video was released implying that the telco had helped inspire January’s revolution.
Such was the level of anger, that JWT MENA was forced to apologise via social media sites last night, with the network saying via Twitter that the “Video circulated is not related to @VodafoneEgypt, but done by #JWT Cairo for presentation purposes & NOT AN AD. We apologize to everyone.”
The apology followed the posting of a video on JWT’s website that combined its award-winning Kowetna campaign with events in Tahrir Square. The end tagline reads: “We didn’t send people to the streets, we didn’t start the revolution … We only reminded Egyptians how powerful they are.”
The posting of the video (above) led to the almost instantaneous creation of the website ihateVodafoneEgypt.com and to bloggers such as Mohamed El Dahsan slamming both the agency and Vodafone, which has since said it had nothing to do with the video.
“Take the time to watch the outrageous Vodafone ad that has sparked public outrage in Egypt this week,” said El Dahsan. “Vodafone, the company that complied with the Mubarak regime’s demands to shutdown communications networks is taking credit for what happened in Tahrir Square.”
A comment piece on the homepage of ihateVodafoneEgypt.com says: “It is really quite sad, and pathetic, when an advertising agency helps a client ride the revolutionary wave and manipulate it, but it’s an entirely different ballgame when they dare to even hint at the idea that their client had anything to do with it. “It is not only arrogant and obnoxious and offensive, it is delusional, when that agency is advertising for one of the mobile companies that took part in the communication blackout that Egypt experienced; Vodafone, the very one that sent us those pro-government messages, seems to think they can play around the timing of an ad that had nothing to do with anything but pure market competition.”
Vodafone issued a statement distancing itself from the video, stating that it denied responsibility for the video. Hatem Dowidar, CEO of Vodafone Egypt, confirmed that “the company does not have any connection to this video and had no prior knowledge of its production or posting on the Internet”. He added that Vodafone Egypt is part of a global company that has strict policies refraining it from associating the brand name with any political or religious affairs of any country in which it operates.
The YouTube video accompanying this article was removed a few hours after the article was posted
I watched the entire video and to be honest, if they had left the beginning tone and indirect nature of the message throughout the ad it wouldn’t have generated such issue. Egyptians know what they are struggling for. Every father and mother fought for their children and for their future. The first part of the ad indirectly said that. No need to dig yourself a hole and jump right in during the second part.
As for VF response saying they know nothing about it, it looks more like the ad was created as a concept internally perhaps as a pitch and never shared. Someone leaked it out.
It looks like an awards entry video to me, probably for Cannes. Little chance of winning now.
Just seems a bit overreactive, seeing how much credit was (and continues to be) given to Facebook.